Main Navigation Menu

Are Altar Calls Really Worth Much?

altar call boy good or bad

I was 14 years old and an eighth-grader when I started going to Wednesday night youth services. Being in the “Bible Belt”, it was kinda the “hip thing” to do; essentially everybody went. We’d get out of school, walk down to the local Subway, grab something to eat, then walk to the First Baptist Church—the typical Wednesday night.

It was always fun—even though that’s not the word that should first come to mind when talking about church. I still have many memories from that church. From playing basketball, playing games, and seeing a classmate of mine fall off a skateboard and bust his teeth everywhere.

Notice none of these memories concern my relationship with God.

There was one night where all of us met up in the huge sanctuary for some reason. The Word was preached, and next thing you know, we heard the typical, “With every head bowed and every eye closed…”

There was about to be an invitation to “accept Jesus into your heart,” …which is another blog for another day.

So I was sitting next to my friend, and the pastor said, “If you truly want to pray that prayer, come up front.” I peaked (because, ya know, my mind really wasn’t on that prayer—sorry God), and my friend got up… so I got up too!

I walked up there with him and a multitude of others; we began to honestly do a dance of praise to God for being saved.

I went home that night feeling the same. I woke up the next morning feeling no different; I had no love for the Lord, I didn’t genuinely care to obey Him, and I definitely didn’t care if God said my sin was sin or not.

Altar Calls Or No Altar Calls?

Was I saved when I went up to the altar?

Absolutely not …but I thought I was saved.

A week or two later, I went to Oklahoma City with the youth group for a trip to a heaven-or-hell-type-of-haunted-house. We went through a little room that symbolized Hell; it was very hot, there was “fire,” and there were prison cells everywhere. Then the A/C was on in the next room, which was a very light room, and my gosh, I was in Heaven! It felt much nicer in there.

After, we all sat down to hear a sermon over Heaven and Hell. Again, the gospel was presented, people—including myself—came forward and “accepted Jesus as their personal Lord and Savior.”

Weeks after that experience, there was still no change—I was still your typical red-blooded 14-year-old boy who really didn’t care much about Christianity (except when he needed help).

Also, another thing that should jump out is the fact that I was “saved” twice in a span of three weeks. If anything shows you that neither experience was genuine, that should be the reason.

(That kind of leads into the theological issue of can you lose or give back your salvation, which I firmly believe that Scripture says you cannot. You’re either saved, or not, but your salvation is of the Lord, not yourself. Also another blog post for another time.)

Two altar calls. Two false conversions. I wasn’t saved.

Are altar calls a bad thing?

Not entirely. They can be, though.

Altar calls, as you can see from my experiences, can be very misleading and dangerous.

They (the altars, not the pastors) give you the false assurance of salvation because you took the time to go down there and pray a prayer. Emotions are high, music is on, and you’re giving into peer pressure. Dare I say it, altar calls can be manipulative. And I am not sure how anybody can argue with me on that.

Hear me though: I am not saying the pastor is in the wrong; I am not saying the church is not in the wrong; I am saying that the modern church has adopted a practice that is very dangerous. It’s not the pastor’s fault; he’s doing his job of preaching the gospel.

That leads me to this question:

Should we do altar calls?

If you want to, then do it. It’s not a sin to give altar calls (duh). I will give altar calls, but as I have said before, I will never affirm somebody’s salvation on the spot, because I have no way of knowing if their conversion is true or not.

Do people get saved at the altar? Absolutely. Do people get false assurance of salvation at the altar? You bet’cha. Probably more than the people who actually get saved.

All in all, altar calls are fine; in my opinion. You should still do them, but do so with extreme caution in the eyes of the Lord. People can and will fall into the trap of relying on their “altar call experience” as to give reason why they’re saved.

You’re not saved because you prayed a prayer at the altar; you’re saved because God granted you faith and repentance. You have faith only because of God; you repent only because God lets you repent.

None of it’s your doing; be humble.

, ,

Comments are closed.

Submit your book recommendation via this form and let us know why you’d recommend it for other guys! Thanks for your suggestions and contributions to the community!

*All accounts you have with TMM are the same account with different permissions. Visit the Join page for more about an Author, Show Host, Vendor, or Network Blogger account! Hit up the shop if all you want is swag.


Support Us?


donate support donations themajestysmen the majesty's men tips jar

If everyone who visits in a month gave $1, we’d be able to pay a full-time staff and fund other endeavors such as the creation of media, books, courses and more to reach and encourage young men! Will you help make this happen? Click this image and tip us any amount.


The Adelphotes Network by


“Adelphós” is greek for “brother”, and so “adelphotés ” is the greek word used in the Bible to refer to the “brotherhood of believers” and the early followers of “the way”, both male and female. We are in the very early stages of building a network of like-minded brothers who seek to make much of Jesus, together. Each site will be guaranteed to be amazing with as much (or little) as you need to produce the content you want to produce with attractive style!

We are currently not open for applications, but if you’re interested, you can submit your info and reserve a place in line to be notified first when we begin accepting applications. Simply go to this page and submit your info.

You can check out a few of the guys who have already taken their sites live on the network and show them some support:

The Gospel Plant

by Gerald White


by Obbie Todd


by Riley Adam Voth

The Majesty's Men Adelphotes Network Brotherhood Blogs Graphic

A network for like-minded brothers.
Find out more!

TMM Podcasts-min

We have a few in the works!
Wanna host one?

A library geared for guys.
(We’ll be finished soon!)

If we’re going to rally together, then let’s use our size to do good for people!
(Coming Soon!)